A new study by iSeeCars analyzed over 700,000 used cars and 368 million odometer readings to identify the most cost-effective five-year-old vehicles based on their price per remaining year of expected lifespan. The findings highlight affordable options for consumers looking for reliable transportation without a high upfront cost.

Top-Ranked Used Cars for the Money
The study ranked vehicles by dividing their average US list price by their estimated remaining lifespan, producing a “price per remaining year” metric. The Honda Fit ranked first, with an average price of $18,336 and an expected remaining lifespan of 11.6 years. This resulted in a cost of $1,583 per remaining year—less than half the overall average of $3,426.
Here are the most reliable 5-year-old used cars for the money:
Best 5-Year-Old Used Cars for the Money – iSeeCars Study | |||||
Rank | Model | Average List Price | Expected Remaining Lifespan (Years) | Price per Remaining Year | Compared to Average |
1 | Honda Fit | $18,336 | 11.6 | $1,583 | 0.46x |
2 | Volkswagen Passat | $17,636 | 9.6 | $1,845 | 0.54x |
3 | Buick Encore | $16,633 | 8.8 | $1,897 | 0.55x |
4 | Kia Rio 5-Door | $14,037 | 6.9 | $2,023 | 0.59x |
5 | Honda Civic | $20,157 | 9.8 | $2,053 | 0.60x |
6 | Mazda Mazda3 (hatchback) | $20,262 | 9.8 | $2,073 | 0.61x |
7 | Mitsubishi Outlander Sport | $15,821 | 7.5 | $2,102 | 0.61x |
8 | Toyota Yaris | $16,427 | 7.6 | $2,148 | 0.63x |
9 | Toyota Corolla | $17,728 | 8.1 | $2,201 | 0.64x |
10 | INFINITI Q50 | $24,000 | 10.6 | $2,261 | 0.66x |
Overall 5-Year-Old Used Car Average | $26,206 | 7.6 | $3,426 | — | |
The study found that the average five-year-old used car costs $26,206 and has 7.6 years of remaining lifespan, costing $3,426 per remaining year.

Best 5-Year-Old Used Hybrids
The study also examined hybrid vehicles, ranking them using the same methodology. The Toyota Prius topped the list, with a remaining lifespan of 9.0 years and a cost of $2,452 per year.
Here are the most reliable 5-year-old used hybrids:
Best 5-Year-Old Used Hybrids for the Money – iSeeCars Study | |||||
Rank | Model | Average List Price | Expected Remaining Lifespan (Years) | Price per Remaining Year | Compared to Average |
1 | Toyota Prius | $22,006 | 9.0 | $2,452 | 0.90x |
2 | Toyota Camry Hybrid | $23,364 | 9.4 | $2,491 | 0.91x |
3 | Ford Fusion Energi | $19,336 | 7.7 | $2,521 | 0.92x |
4 | Toyota Avalon Hybrid | $28,901 | 10.8 | $2,665 | 0.97x |
5-Year-Old Hybrid Average | $23,652 | 8.6 | $2,735 | — | |
5 | Ford Fusion Hybrid | $17,808 | 5.3 | $3,333 | 1.22x |
6 | Lexus RX 450h | $39,172 | 11.5 | $3,407 | 1.25x |
7 | Toyota Highlander Hybrid | $34,172 | 9.8 | $3,490 | 1.28x |
8 | Lexus RX 450hL | $40,148 | 11.5 | $3,492 | 1.28x |
9 | Hyundai Sonata Hybrid | $20,358 | 5.8 | $3,524 | 1.29x |
10 | Ford Escape Hybrid | $20,437 | 5.2 | $3,950 | 1.44x |
The study found that the average five-year-old hybrid costs $23,652 and has an average lifespan of 8.6 years, or $2,735 per remaining year.
Other Key Findings
- The average 10-year-old used car costs $15,655, with an average remaining lifespan of 6 years ($2,609 per year).
- The Honda Fit ranks as the most reliable five- and ten-year-old used car for the money, with an expected lifespan of 11.6 years.
- The Tesla Model S is the only electric vehicle among the top 10 most reliable 10-year-old used cars.
- SUVs remain a popular choice, with five-year-old models averaging below $25,000 and an expected lifespan of 7.6 years.
The full study, including rankings for trucks and SUVs, is available on iSeeCars’ website.

