Tuesday, December 7, 2021
News Real-World EV Range Tests Find Discrepancies With EPA Estimates

Real-World EV Range Tests Find Discrepancies With EPA Estimates

The debate over range and ratings is being fueled by Edmunds’ test results


  • Edmunds has discovered that Tesla vehicles do not deliver indicated ranges.

  • A Tesla Model 3 Long Range still tops the chart.

  • The Porsche Taycan is the most underrated EV.


An electric vehicle’s range remains its strongest asset. Like muscle cars during the horsepower wars (still ongoing), an electric vehicle is only as worthy as its EPA-estimated range. The Environmental Protection Agency has long held the “truth” on efficiency however growing discrepancies between their range numbers and the real world have invited challengers to their methods and data. The latest and perhaps most credible is Edmunds.

In brief, Edmunds has found that their real-world outdoor tests poke numerous holes in the EPA’s range numbers. According to Edmunds, the EPA’s indoor dynamometer-based tests deliver results that can be far from reality.

2020 Tesla Model Y | Photo: Tesla

Perhaps most “shocking” is that every Tesla they’ve evaluated has failed to meet their EPA-estimated ranges. Even so, a Model 3 Long Range still earned the crown for the longest range but even so, some Tesla vehicles fell 10% short. The big winner, and one that’s been a topic of debate since its introduction, is the Porsche Taycan. Nearly all who’ve driven a Taycan, including ourselves, have found that the estimated range numbers fell dramatically short of the car’s potential. In fact, Edmunds managed nearly 60% more distance than the EPA’s posted range.

Other “winners” following Edmunds test loops include the Ford Mustang Mach-E, Mini Cooper SE, the all-new Volkswagen ID.4, and the near entirety of the Hyundai Groups family of EVs.

If you’re curious or shopping for an EV, Edmunds’ work is worth a look.

Volkswagen ID.4 | Photo: Volkswagen

Trending Now

2022 Ford Maverick Hybrid Sold Out Until Mid-2022

Hybrid version order books to reopen by mid-2022 for 2023 model year. The Maverick Hybrid starts at $25,900 in Canada. The Hybrid’s powertrain...

EV Batteries are Coming Down in Price

Prices per kilowatt-hour are much lower than they were a couple of years ago This will bring EVs at price parity with gasoline...

Mazda MX-30 Will be Available With Rotary Engine Range Extender

This MX-30 will be a plug-in-hybrid. Range details are unknown. The MX-30 PHEV arrives next year. We happen to be test-driving a 2022 Mazda...

Mazda Uses a New Assembly Line Design that Makes Production More Flexible

Instead of conveyors and hangers, cars are moved by underground tracks This system allows for quick changes to accommodate different body styles and...

Subaru Has 45,000 Back Orders in the US

Inventories are down to a 5-day supply. Normal levels are at 45 days. The global chip shortage is to blame. Subaru was on a...
Matt St-Pierre
Trained as an Automotive Technician, Matt has two decades of automotive journalism under his belt. He’s done TV, radio, print and this thing called the internet. He’s an avid collector of many 4-wheeled things, all of them under 1,500 kg, holds a recently expired racing license and is a father of two. Life is beautiful. Send Matt an emai

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.