2025 Acura Integra Type S vs 2025 BMW M2: Manual Mastery, Two Ways

• BMW M2’s manual requires commitment, but rewards with raw, rear-wheel-drive excellence.

• Acura’s Type S is instantly intuitive: fun, fast, and forgiving, even for novice drivers.

• These are two of the last great manuals so buy either, and you’ll never regret the kilometres.

We’re well past the halfway mark of 2025, and it’s time we faced the truth: the manual transmission is hanging by a thread. Old News perhaps. Automakers are turning to automatics, CVTs, and dual-clutches in the name of chasing efficiency, speed, and, let’s be honest, ease. But a few brands haven’t given up. Mazda still gives us joy in the MX-5. Porsche remains faithful with the 911 and 718 (dead at the time of writing these words). And then we’ve got two of my favourites in BMW and Acura, both proudly offering a proper six-speed.

So here we are, pitting the 2025 BMW M2 against the 2025 Acura Integra Type S. I know, I know, one costs more than 50% more than the other. But this isn’t about price. This is about the drive, the stick, and the connection between car and driver. My mission? Find out which one I’d actually buy and why.

BMW M2: The Heavy-Hitting Purist

Let’s start with the BMW. Why? Because it’s expensive, obviously.

The 2025 M2 starts at $78,300, and this one with the Java Green paint, carbon roof, and a few other goodies comes to $92,250. Under the hood is a turbocharged 3.0L inline-six, pushing out 473 hp and 406 lb-ft of torque. Rear-wheel drive. Manual gearbox. Adaptive M suspension. Big brakes. And a whole lot of attitude.

I’ve been fortunate enough to drive BMW manuals for over two and a half decades, back to the E46 3 Series in the early 2000s. And if there’s one thing that’s remained constant, it’s this: BMW doesn’t change what isn’t broken. The six-speed in this M2 feels nearly identical to the one I drove in 2001. And that’s a good thing.

But it’s not easy. The clutch is heavy and springy. The shifter feels rubbery. There’s no mechanical snick into gear, no click or notch. It’s heavy-vague at times, almost frustrating. And yet, that’s its charm. The BMW manual isn’t something you tame; it tames you.

There’s a learning curve. But once you crest that hill, the payoff is massive. You start syncing with it, understanding how it wants to be driven. Suddenly, you’re carving corners, rev-matching perfectly, and laughing like an idiot because it all clicks.

Toss in a properly wild chassis, a snarling exhaust, and rear-wheel drive that loves to play, and the M2 becomes an absolute animal on the right road. It’s heavy, but compact. Powerful, but manageable. In the right hands and with enough patience, it’s one of the most involving cars on sale today.

Acura Integra Type S: The Natural Choice

Now, hop out of the M2 and slide into the Acura Integra, and everything changes.

The Integra Type S costs just $57,100 to start or $58,700 as tested in Apex Blue with synthetic leather seats. So no, it’s not “cheap,” but it feels like a bargain next to the BMW.

Under the hood? A masterful turbocharged 2.0L four-cylinder good for 320 hp and 310 lb-ft. Power goes to the front wheels through a six-speed manual shifter that feels like a phantom limb. You get adaptive dampers, a limited-slip diff, and a personality that blends daily comfort with weekend insanity.

And here’s the kicker: within five seconds of driving it, you feel like it was built just for you.

Everything about this car is intuitive. The clutch is light but communicative. The shifter is short, precise, and satisfying in every throw. The friction point is friendly. The car doesn’t punish you for imperfect timing; it works with you, not against you.

That’s the secret Honda sauce, and Acura has it dialled. I’ve said before that the Civic Type R is nothing short of the Porsche 911 GT3 of affordable hot hatches. The Integra Type S? It’s right there with it. Slightly more refined for the gentleman or gentlewoman in you.

And despite being a front-wheel drive vehicle, there’s never a compromise to be met or felt. The power delivery is sharp, the steering is tight, and the Type S rotates beautifully through corners. You can toss it, trail brake, dance on the throttle, and it never falls apart.

Plus, it’s practical. I once shoved a full-size bicycle into the hatch. Try doing that in a Cayman.

Which Would I Buy?

Well, here’s the thing. There are no losers here. These are two of the last great manuals you can buy new. They’re both brilliant, but in very different ways.

The BMW M2 is a workout. It demands patience, skill, and commitment. But once you’ve learned its ways, it rewards you with raw, visceral thrills. It’s the car you drive when you want to work for it and win.

The Integra Type S, on the other hand, just gets you. It’s forgiving, fun, and every bit as involving, but in a friendlier, more accessible way. You could drive it to work, hit the track, and haul your kids and groceries without ever missing a beat. It’s the car that makes you a better driver, without needing to make excuses.

Now, would I drop $100K on the M2? Maybe. If I had a fat tax return and no kids. But if you gave me $60K today and said, “Buy a car you’ll love driving every day,” I’d take the keys to the Integra, no hesitation.

Manuals are fading. But as long as cars like these exist, there’s still hope. Just don’t wait too long because the next time we do a similar test, one or all of them might be gone.

2025 Acura Intergra Type S VS 2025 BMW M2

1 of 43