Should You Buy a 2025 BMW Z4?

I still remember the first time I laid eyes on the original BMW Z4, back when the Chris Bangle era was in full swing. With its bold design and unmistakable roadster charm, it was a car that captured my imagination instantly. Those early Z4s were perfect in their own way, offering a pure driving experience that made every journey feel special.

Fast forward to the second generation, and BMW introduced the Z4 Coupe—a move that solidified the Z4’s design as pure perfection, especially in the M variant, with its iconic long-hood, short-deck silhouette. But anyway, I digress, let’s go back to our roadster. Now, here I am with the 2025 Z4, equipped with a 6-speed manual transmission, and it feels like a return to form.

This car maintains everything that made the Z4 appealing in the first place—engaging driving dynamics, a balanced chassis with rear-wheel drive, a high-quality interior that wraps you in luxury, and most of all, the return of rowing your own gears with the manual transmission introduction for the 2025 model year.

It’s a perfect blend of performance and refinement, yet it doesn’t come without its drawbacks. For sports car enthusiasts like myself, the Z4 m40i with a manual transmission is a rare treat, offering a level of driver engagement that’s becoming increasingly scarce in today’s market. It’s proof that BMW still knows how to cater to those who value the connection between car and driver, even if it’s not without a few compromises.

Why You Should Buy a 2025 BMW Z4

• The Hearts of a Purist: The 2025 Z4 offers two refined turbocharged engines that deliver eager performance without sacrificing fuel efficiency. You can choose between a 255 hp 2.0L turbo four-cylinder or a robust 382 hp 3.0L turbo inline-six. During my test week with the M40i, I achieved an impressive 9.0L/100 km fuel economy, with about 80% of my driving on the highway. The four-cylinder model is even more frugal, boasting a combined fuel economy of 8.4 L/100 km.
• Tailored for Enthusiasts: BMW hasn’t simply bolted on a manual transmission and called it a day. The “Handschalter” variant comes with bespoke chassis tuning, including unique auxiliary springs and a reinforced anti-roll bar clamp. These tweaks sharpen the car’s responses and elevate the overall driving experience.
• Striking the Right Balance: While the Z4 has always been a capable cruiser, the M40i variant offers a more involving drive without sacrificing comfort. The adaptive M suspension with electronically controlled dampers remains standard, ensuring the car handles daily driving duties with ease and precision.
• A Potential Collector’s Item: Perhaps the most exciting news for driving enthusiasts is the availability of a 6-speed manual transmission on the M40i model. This option enhances driver engagement and provides a more involved driving experience. The manual version also benefits from unique chassis tuning, improving handling dynamics. Given the industry trend towards automatics, this could potentially be the last model year with a manual option, making it a future collector’s item.
• Silk Road Cruiser – Comfort is King: Unlike some high-strung sports cars, the Z4 is designed for relaxed day-to-day cruising. It offers a composed ride quality and a remarkably quiet interior, even with the top down. This makes it an ideal companion for long drives or daily commutes.
• Spacious and Practical for a Roadster: One of the Z4’s standout features is its roomy cabin, which comfortably accommodates taller drivers – a rarity in the roadster segment. The convertible top is cleverly designed not to intrude on cargo space when lowered, adding to the car’s practicality. Despite being a two-seater, the Z4 manages to avoid the claustrophobic feeling often associated with roadsters.

Why You Should Not Buy a 2025 BMW Z4

• Performance Trade-offs: While the manual transmission offers a more engaging drive, it does come with some compromises. The 0-100 km/h sprint takes 4.4 seconds, which is 0.5 seconds slower than the automatic version. For some, this might be a small price to pay for the joy of rowing their own gears.
• Limited Availability: The manual transmission is only available on the top-tier M40i model, which may put it out of reach for some buyers who would have preferred a manual option on the less expensive sDrive30i variant.
• Less Engaging Than Some Rivals: While the Z4 is undoubtedly fun to drive, it may not provide the same level of thrills or engagement as some competitors, such as the Porsche Boxster.
• Subtlety Over Spectacle: The Z4’s exterior design, while handsome, may be considered somewhat plain compared to more striking roadsters in its class. If you’re looking for a head-turner, there might be more visually dramatic options available.
• Limited Interior Storage: Despite its practical trunk space, the Z4’s cabin offers limited storage for small items. This could be an inconvenience for those who like to have their essentials within easy reach while driving.
• Luxury Comes at a Price: With a starting price of $69,000 for the base model in Canada, the Z4 represents a significant investment. Opting for the manual transmission, which is only available on the M40i ($82,000 starting price), adds quite a lot to the price tag.

Conclusion

The 2025 BMW Z4 M40i with the 6-speed manual represents a calculated gamble by BMW. By offering this transmission option, they’re catering to a vocal but potentially shrinking segment of driving enthusiasts. The manual Z4 M40i trades some performance metrics for a more engaging driving experience, which may resonate with purists but could limit its broader appeal.

This version of the Z4 highlights an interesting crossroads in the automotive industry. As we move towards electrification and increased automation, cars like this manual Z4 become increasingly rare. For some drivers, this scarcity will enhance its appeal. For others, it may seem like a step backwards.

Ultimately, the success of this model will depend on whether enough buyers are willing to put their money where their mouths are. BMW has listened to enthusiasts’ demands, but will these enthusiasts follow through with purchases? Only time will tell.

What’s clear is that the 2025 BMW Z4 M40i with the 6-speed manual offers a distinctive driving experience in today’s market. It’s a choice that prioritizes driver involvement over convenience, harking back to a different era of sports cars. Whether that’s enough to justify its premium price tag and potential drawbacks is a decision each buyer will have to make for themselves.

2025 BMW Z4 M40i

1 of 38